Classic Eggnog

I make not secret about it: I love Eggnog. Even as a kid, I enjoyed the weird stuff that came in a carton from the grocery store (which, let’s be honest with ourselves, isn’t Eggnog, at least not Classic Eggnog). Heck, in college when I worked at McDonald’s, I helped myself to a fair few Eggnog Shakes. However, I had a revelation when I had true, authentic, Classic Eggnog (with bourbon!). If you haven’t tried it — oh, for me, for yourself, for the children! — give it a try.

separate the eggscream

First things first: yes, there are raw eggs in it. If you’re super freaked out about such things, buy good quality, fresh, organic eggs. Then don’t mishandle them.

Or, if you really just can’t stomach the idea, get some pasteurized eggs. If Louis (Pasteur, stick with me here), says they’re good, they’re good.

Though, in the many years that I’ve used raw eggs in things, following safe and smart practices, I’ve had zero issues whatsoever with them. The key is being smart about what you’re doing.

whip egg whitesstiff egg whites

Now, as it’s a celebratory drink, don’t skimp on the cream or whole milk. You’re not going to drink this every day or even every week. However, you are going to drink it around Christmas, with friends and family, while enjoying mirth and merriment, hopefully eating some cookies and some fudge. As that’s only a once a year season, live it up a little.

With the nutmeg, I’m sure you all know by now to use whole and grate it yourself. Unlike other spices, whole nutmeg will last darn near forever. Keep it around and grate as needed (say on some homemade mac and cheese or any béchamel you’ve whipped up).

When you’re done making the Classic Eggnog (individual portions here, scale up as needed), then you can add your splash (or three) of bourbon to individual glasses. Maybe there are some kids around who want to discover the joy of true, authentic, Classic Eggnog, but are a bit young to try it with some bourbon.

Now, onto the Classic Eggnog!

fold in egg whitesbulleit bourbon

Classic Eggnog
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 1
  • 1 egg yolk
  • 1 tbs. + 1 tsp. sugar
  • ½ cup whole milk
  • ¼ cup heavy cream
  • Freshly grated nutmeg
  • 1 egg white
  • Bourbon
  • Glass type: Mug
  1. Whisk the egg yolk until it's pale, then add 1 tbs. of the sugar and whisk it all together.
  2. Using baking sugar (the ultra fine stuff) will help the sugar dissolve.
  3. Next, add the milk and cream to your yolk and sugar mixture.
  4. Whisk together.
  5. Grate on some nutmeg.
  6. In a seperate bowl, whisk the egg white and remaining 1 tsp. of sugar together until you get what they like to call "stiff peaks."
  7. Finally, whisk the egg whites into drink.
  8. Then pour into your mugs or drink vessel of choice.
  9. Grate a little extra nutmeg on top and serve.
  10. Oh, add a splash of bourbon or three in there if that's your thing (it's mine).
  11. Now get out there and get festive!